McKinley’s Cafe Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to McKinley’s Cafe, a delightful haven tucked away on Main St, Shelbyville. This gem specializes in a vibrant menu that caters to both classic and adventurous palates. Guests rave about their creative paninis and mouthwatering sandwiches, all crafted with care and topped off by friendly service. The café is particularly renowned for its homemade desserts, including delectable cakes and cookies.

Charles Riggs describes his experience as a joyful exploration, praising the diverse offerings that range from satisfying soups to scrumptious sides. Locals like Joselyn D have made the 615 sandwich a staple, while Shanna Morgan highlights the affordability and generous portions that leave diners feeling both happy and full.

At McKinley’s Cafe, expect a warm atmosphere, exceptional service, and an emphasis on fresh ingredients, making it a must-visit spot for lunch enthusiasts and food lovers alike.

Salad

Garden Salad

Pineapple Salad

Chef Salad

Greek Salad

Southwest Salad

Potato Salad

Pasta Salad

Cookies

US$1.00

Bars

US$2.50

Desserts

Beverages

Sweet Tea

Unsweet Tea

US$20.00

Raspberry Tea

Lemonade

US$20.00

Coke

US$1.75

Sprite

US$1.75

Bottled Water

US$1.25

Turkey & Swiss

Turkey & Goat Cheese

Gouda & Turkey

Italian Melt

Artichoke & Pepper Jack

Spicy Roast Beef

Ham, Cheese, & Apple

Firenze

Tuscanini

Reuben

Paninis

Drinks

Unsweet

US$2.25

Soda

Mckinley

Sante Fe

Shelby

Turkey Apricot Wrap

Tuscany

Club

Sandwiches

Soup

Soup Of The Day

US$3.75

Legendary Chili

US$4.00

Side Salad

Cup Of Chili

Cup Of Soup

Pasta Salad

Potato Salad

Chips

Sides

Others

Tomato Basil

Custom Soup

Cucumber Soup

Mckinley

Shelby

Turkey Apricot Wraps

Pimento On Sundried Tomato Focaccia

Soup Of The Day

US$3.75

Legendary Chili

US$4.00

Build Your Own Sandwich

Chips: Lays, Baked Lays, Sun Chips, Bbq Chips

Salad

US$5.00